Gabb suits a younger child who only needs to call and text home and a parent who wants zero internet with no settings to manage. The Bark Phone suits a family that wants one device to start locked down and open up gradually, with AI alerts on messages and social apps.
- Gabb phones have no web browser, no open app store and no social media.
- The Bark Phone is a Samsung Galaxy running a custom locked-down Android that can't be factory reset to remove controls, per the video.
- Gabb: about $150 for the phone plus plans of about $25, $30 or $35 a month, as of the video.
- Bark: phone financed over 24 months (about $10/month standard, $25/month Pro) plus plans from about $30 to almost $80 a month, as of the video.
- Every Bark Phone plan includes Bark Premium, which covers the family's other devices too.
Some of these are partner links; they cost you nothing extra. How we earn
On this page11 sections
Bark and Gabb both sell themselves as safe phones for kids, but they protect children in opposite ways. Gabb is a wall: it keeps the open internet off the device entirely. Bark is a bridge: a full smartphone that lets a child move toward independence while software watches for trouble.
Our video compared them on four things: the safety philosophy behind each, how they handle a tech-savvy kid trying to get around the rules, monitoring versus blocking, and how well each one lasts as a child grows. Bark sponsored that video and the presenter prefers Bark, so we've been careful to keep the case for Gabb and to say who should skip Bark. If you're weighing the Bark app rather than the phone, see our Bark review and Qustodio vs Bark.
Quick verdict
The video's pick is the Bark Phone: real Samsung hardware, firmware-level lockdown, AI alerts on messages and social apps, and plans you can open up or lock down month to month without buying a new phone. Gabb is the better choice if you want a simple first phone for a younger child with no internet at all, no monitoring to manage and a lower, predictable bill.
What they have in common
Both are phones built for children rather than adult phones with an app bolted on. Both handle calls and texts, both are designed to stop a child wandering into the open internet unsupervised, and both have tiered monthly plans that add features as you move up. Either can work as a first phone for a child who needs to call home after soccer practice or arrange a ride.
The big split: a wall vs a bridge
Gabb works by subtraction. You get a curated, isolated system with no web browser, no open app store and no social media. For a parent of a younger child this is very appealing: it is set-and-forget. You don't have to worry about what they search for, because the internet simply doesn't exist on the device.
The Bark Phone works by supervision. It is a fully functional Samsung Galaxy, able to do anything a regular phone does, with a software layer on top that uses AI monitoring to watch for danger. The idea is that kids will meet the internet sooner or later, for school research, friends or curiosity, and they need a chaperone rather than a blackout.
The video adds that Bark can be locked down as tightly as Gabb if that is what your child needs now. The difference is that you can change those settings later instead of buying another phone.
If your priority is total exclusion and delaying your child's exposure to the internet as long as possible, the video says Gabb is the clear choice.
Tamper-proofing for tech-savvy kids
If there's a way round a restriction, a bored 12-year-old will find it. Gabb deals with this by having nothing to break out to: it runs a closed, proprietary operating system, and the tools a child would need to escape (a browser, an app installer) simply aren't there. That makes it effective but rigid.
Bark takes standard Samsung hardware and runs a custom locked-down version of Android. According to the video, the protections sit at the firmware level: a factory reset won't wipe the parental controls, there's no uninstall button for the safety features, and changing the system clock or using a VPN won't get around time limits. The controls are built into the phone rather than added as a regular app.
The video's view is that both are strong here, and that Bark is the sturdier option if you want a phone that stays smart and still resists tampering.
Monitoring vs blocking
Gabb's safety comes from simplicity. There's no AI or alert engine running in the background; the child is safe by default because there's so little on the phone. Parents can still check texts if they want to.
Bark treats the phone as a busy place and reads the context. Its machine learning looks across texts, email and dozens of supported social apps for signs of bullying, predatory behaviour or self-harm, and alerts you only when it detects a real concern. On top of that you get detailed control over how the phone behaves: for example, only educational apps during school hours, with social apps unlocking automatically after homework.
If AI monitoring feels too complicated or intrusive for your family, Gabb's blocked-by-design approach may be enough. If your teen is going to be online anyway and you want to hear about high-risk situations before they escalate, Gabb doesn't offer anything like Bark's contextual alerts.
How each phone grows with your child
The video calls this the biggest trap: buying a safe phone your child outgrows in 12 months. Gabb, as the video describes it, is a fixed environment. It works well for the first-phone phase, but if a 12-year-old needs a browser for school projects or a specific app for a sports team, you either go without or buy a different phone, move their data and set up monitoring again.
Bark changes the plan, not the hardware. You can start on a basic plan that is as locked down as a dedicated kids' phone (just talk and text), then upgrade through the parent app to allow apps and the browser as your child earns more trust, and drop back to the basic plan to return the phone to a distraction-free state if needed. You can also adjust how sensitive the AI alerts are, so the same phone is set differently for an 8-year-old and a 16-year-old. It is also a real Samsung Galaxy, which looks like a normal phone rather than a toy. That matters to a lot of teenagers.
Plans and pricing
| Gabb | Bark Phone | |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Wall: internet kept off the phone | Bridge: full smartphone, supervised |
| Hardware | Gabb's own phone, about $150 upfront | Samsung Galaxy, buy outright or 24 months at 0% (about $10/month standard, $25/month Pro) |
| Entry plan | About $25/month: unlimited talk and text, no group or picture messaging | From about $30/month |
| Higher plans | About $30/month adds group and picture messaging and Gabb Music; about $35/month adds mobile data | Up to almost $80/month for unlimited data |
| Monitoring | Parents can check texts; no AI engine | AI alerts on texts, email and social apps on every plan |
| Other devices | Not covered | Bark Premium included, covering laptops and tablets in the house |
| Tamper resistance | Closed system, nothing to escape to | Firmware-level controls survive a factory reset |
| Best for | Younger kids, first phone, zero internet | Kids heading into middle school and beyond |
On the monthly bill Gabb looks cheaper, and for a single basic line for one young child it may well be. The video's counterpoint is that every Bark Phone plan includes a full Bark Premium subscription, which the video puts at $14 a month on its own, and that it covers every other device in the house too. It also argues you should count the cost of a replacement phone if your child outgrows Gabb, which the video says is common around middle school. All prices are approximate and as of the video (August 2026).
Who should skip each
- Skip the Bark Phone if you don't want software reading your child's messages and social apps, if you'd rather not manage plan tiers, schedules and alert settings, or if all you need is a cheap line so a young child can call home. Its plans start higher than Gabb's and go up to almost $80 a month, plus the cost of the phone.
- Skip Gabb if your child is approaching middle school and will soon need a browser or specific apps for school, sport or friends. You may end up buying a second phone within a year. Skip it too if you want to be alerted to bullying or predatory contact rather than relying on blocking alone.
Which to pick
- Get Gabb for a younger child's first phone when the goal is calls, texts and no internet at all, and you want it simple and predictable.
- Get the Bark Phone if you want one device to last from a locked-down first phone into the teen years, if your child will be online soon anyway, or if you'd value Bark covering the family's other devices on the same bill.
Whichever you choose, talk to your child about why the phone is set up the way it is. No phone replaces that conversation.
Pros and cons
What works
- Gabb: no browser, app store or social media, so there's nothing to manage.
- Gabb: lower, simple monthly plans.
- Bark: real Samsung Galaxy with firmware-level controls.
- Bark: AI alerts plus plans that open up or lock down as your child grows; Bark Premium included.
What doesn't
- Gabb: rigid; children can outgrow it, which may mean buying a second phone.
- Gabb: no contextual alerts for bullying or predatory contact.
- Bark: higher plan prices plus the cost of the phone.
- Bark: relies on AI reading your child's messages, which not every family wants.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Gabb phone have internet?
Not in the open sense. As the video describes it, Gabb phones have no web browser, no open app store and no social media. The higher plan adds mobile data and music features, but the phone stays a closed system.
Can a kid factory reset a Bark Phone to remove the controls?
According to the video, no. The Bark Phone's controls sit at the firmware level, so a factory reset doesn't wipe them, there's no uninstall button, and changing the clock or using a VPN doesn't get around time limits.
Which is cheaper, Bark or Gabb?
Gabb, on the monthly bill: about $150 for the phone and about $25 to $35 a month, as of the video. Bark plans start around $30 a month plus the phone, but every plan includes Bark Premium for the family's other devices.
What age is each phone for?
Gabb fits a younger child's first phone. The Bark Phone can start just as locked down and be opened up through the teen years, so it suits families who want one device from about 8 to 16.
Is the Bark Phone the same as the Bark app?
No. The Bark app is a monitoring subscription you install on existing devices. The Bark Phone is a locked-down Samsung Galaxy, and its plans include the Bark Premium app subscription. Our Bark review covers the app.
The simplest test is age and timing. If your child only needs to reach you and won't need a browser for a while, Gabb keeps things easy. If they're a year or two from needing apps and the web, a phone that can grow with them saves you starting over.
Filed under
More in Parental Control
ReviewBark Phone Review: What It Really Costs Over 24 MonthsThe Bark Phone puts parental controls in the operating system so they can't be uninstalled. Here's how it works, the full 24-month cost, and who should buy it.
ReviewBark Review: A Parental Control App That Alerts Instead of BlocksHow Bark's alert-based monitoring works, what it costs on Android and iPhone, where it falls short, and which families it suits better than a lockdown app.
ComparisonQustodio vs Bark: Which Parental Control App Fits Your Family?Qustodio shows you everything; Bark only tells you when something looks wrong. How they compare on control, iPhone support, privacy, price and age.