Spot & Tango's UnKibble worked best overall for a picky dog because it was consistent and easy to manage. The Farmer's Dog got the biggest reaction from the dog but takes daily fresh-food effort.
- Five brands were tested on one picky dog, ranked from least to most successful.
- The Farmer's Dog won on how much the dog loved it; Spot & Tango won overall on consistency and ease.
- Spot & Tango cost about $12–$18 a week with the introductory discount.
- Nom Nom cost about $60 a week for the chicken and turkey recipes tested.
Some of these are partner links; they cost you nothing extra. How we earn
On this page10 sections
- Quick verdict
- How we tested
- 5. Nom Nom: fine, but forgettable for the price
- 4. Ollie: variety that didn't matter to our dog
- 3. Sundays for Dogs: easy to manage, but he lost interest
- 2. The Farmer's Dog: the one he loved most
- 1. Spot & Tango UnKibble: the best overall
- How the five compare
- Pros and cons
- Frequently asked questions
If you have already tried a few dog foods and your dog still leaves food in the bowl, looks low on energy, or just isn't as healthy as you'd expect, the problem is usually fit rather than a lack of options. We tested five premium brands on Theodore, a very picky eater, and ranked them from the one that worked the least to the one that worked the best.
This is not a generic ranking. It reflects what actually worked for one dog in real life, judged on a mix of how he responded and how easy the food is to stick with long term.
Quick verdict
Spot & Tango (its UnKibble) was the best overall: Theodore ate it from day one, his energy and digestion looked steadier, and there was no freezer or thawing routine. The Farmer's Dog got the strongest reaction by far, but it is fresh-frozen, so you commit to daily handling. The other three were fine but not memorable enough for the price.
Get Spot & Tango Get The Farmer's Dog Get Nom Nom Get Ollie Get Sundays for Dogs
How we tested
Each food went to the same dog, a picky eater who normally needs a couple of weeks to accept anything new. Where it made sense we mixed the new food with the old one to ease the transition. We judged each brand on how willingly the dog ate it, whether we noticed any change in energy or digestion, how much work it was to store and serve, and what it cost.
5. Nom Nom: fine, but forgettable for the price
Nom Nom starts with a short quiz about your dog's age, weight and breed, then builds a full meal plan with portions already calculated. Recipes include chicken, beef, turkey and pork. We chose chicken and turkey, and the box arrived insulated with ice packs.
Theodore ate around it at first, then finished the bowl within a couple of days. After two weeks there was no dramatic change in energy or behavior. It just made for a smoother, more consistent eating experience. The plan came to about $60 a week for the two recipes we picked, and that varies with your dog's size, activity and needs.
Bottom line: the meals and the ordering system were smooth, but at that price we needed more than "fine".
4. Ollie: variety that didn't matter to our dog
Ollie's pitch is rotation: cycle through recipes so your dog doesn't get bored. For a picky eater that sounded promising. Theodore ate every recipe (turkey, beef and chicken) without hesitation or complaint, but his reaction was identical across all of them, with the same energy and the same interest.
The variety was real, it just didn't change anything for him, and the weekly effort of managing fresh food didn't feel justified when nothing was shifting.
3. Sundays for Dogs: easy to manage, but he lost interest
Sundays is air-dried food: not fresh, not kibble, somewhere in between. Slow, low-temperature drying keeps more of the nutrients without refrigeration, which struck us as a smart format. For the first couple of weeks Theodore ate it consistently, though not enthusiastically.
Then we removed his old food entirely. He sniffed the bowl and walked away. It is one of the easiest options to manage, but if your dog doesn't stick with it after the transition, convenience doesn't matter.
2. The Farmer's Dog: the one he loved most
Out of everything on the list, this is the food Theodore loved. He was finishing the bowl from day one, didn't need the mixing step, and seemed more excited at mealtime than he had in a long time. Pricing came to roughly $2–$6 a day depending on the dog's size and needs.
The catch is the routine. It is fresh and frozen, so you are thawing ahead of time, storing it properly and being careful about handling to avoid cross-contamination. It isn't complicated, but it is constant, every single day, and that adds up in a way that's easy to underestimate.
Bottom line: if you're measuring purely by how much your dog loves the food, nothing else on this list came close. Loving the food and being practical to keep up are two different things, though.
1. Spot & Tango UnKibble: the best overall
After The Farmer's Dog we knew what we wanted: something Theodore would eat consistently that we could manage consistently, without rebuilding the day around feeding time. Spot & Tango's UnKibble is dry food made by gently drying real food at low temperature, which the company says keeps up to 99% of the nutrients, flavor and aroma. The ingredients are real meat, vegetables and whole grains.
We tried the turkey and sweet potato and the beef and barley recipes, and served them without any gradual transition to see his honest reaction. He ate right away. Over the next few days his energy seemed more stable through the day, he settled better after eating, and his digestion was more consistent. It was a quieter change than a dramatic overnight one, but it kept showing up.
The practical side is where it separated itself: no freezer, no thawing schedule, no prep. You open the bag, scoop and go. With the introductory discount it came to about $12–$18 a week, roughly half what some fresh options cost. The price does adjust after the first few weeks, so factor that in.
The video description lists the coupon code CONSUMER50 for a discount on Spot & Tango; offers change, so confirm at checkout.
How the five compare
| Brand | Format | Cost we saw | Our take |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spot & Tango | Gently dried (UnKibble) | ~$12–$18/week with intro discount | Best overall: consistent and easy |
| The Farmer's Dog | Fresh, frozen | ~$2–$6/day | Dog loved it most; daily effort |
| Sundays for Dogs | Air-dried | n/a in our test | Easy, but he walked away after the switch |
| Ollie | Fresh, rotating recipes | n/a in our test | Variety didn't change his response |
| Nom Nom | Fresh, personalized plan | ~$60/week (2 recipes) | Fine, but not memorable |
Pros and cons
What works
- Spot & Tango needs no freezer, thawing or prep.
- The Farmer's Dog produced the strongest reaction from a picky dog.
- Most brands build a plan from your dog's age, weight and breed, so you don't calculate portions.
What doesn't
- Fresh and frozen options mean daily handling and storage.
- Nom Nom is on the premium side and didn't stand out for the cost.
- Spot & Tango's price rises after the introductory period.
- One dog is one data point. Your dog may react differently.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best premium dog food for a picky eater?
In our test, Spot & Tango's UnKibble worked best overall because the dog ate it immediately and it was easy to keep up. The Farmer's Dog got the biggest reaction but takes more daily effort.
Is fresh dog food worth the extra effort?
It depends on your routine. The Farmer's Dog was the food our dog loved most, but thawing, storing and handling it every day is a real commitment. A gently dried food gave us most of the benefit with less work.
How should I switch my dog to a new food?
We mixed the new food with the old one at first, as we normally do. With Spot & Tango we skipped the gradual transition to see his honest reaction and he ate it right away. Go slower if your dog has a sensitive stomach.
Do these links cost extra?
No. They are affiliate links, so we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you, and some links give access to deals that aren't on the brands' own sites.
Filed under
More in Pets
ComparisonWe Feed Raw vs The Farmer's Dog: Raw or Gently Cooked?Raw against gently cooked: we compared We Feed Raw and The Farmer's Dog on ingredients, recipes, price for a 43 lb dog, and customer service. The Farmer's Dog edged it overall.
ReviewSmalls Cat Food Review: Is Fresh Food Worth It for a Picky Cat?We put a picky cat named Rocky on Smalls for a few weeks: the recipes and textures, how the plan works, what each meal costs, and the catches.
ReviewUnKibble by Spot & Tango Review: Worth the Price?A few weeks with UnKibble, Spot & Tango's gently dried dog food: ingredients, per-meal cost, digestion, convenience, and how it compares with The Farmer's Dog.