The Helix Midnight Luxe is our best overall pick because it has no weak spot. Pick the Leesa Sapira Chill if you sleep hot, Saatva for a hotel feel with setup included, Nectar for motion isolation on a budget, or Brooklyn's Aurora Luxe for firmness choice.
- Helix Midnight Luxe: a zoned hybrid at about 6/10 firmness, from about $1,900 for a queen.
- Nectar Premier: 13 inches of memory foam, a 365-night trial, from about $1,000 for a queen.
- Saatva Classic: coil-on-coil with delivery and setup included, from about $1,900 for a queen.
- Every mattress here gives at least a 100-night trial.
Some of these are partner links; they cost you nothing extra. How we earn
On this page9 sections
- Quick verdict
- 1. Helix Midnight Luxe: best overall
- 2. Leesa Sapira Chill: for hot sleepers who want a soft top
- 3. Saatva Classic: for people who don't want a bed in a box
- 4. Nectar Premier: best for motion isolation and budget
- 5. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe: for firmness choice
- The five side by side
- Pros and cons
- Frequently asked questions
Every mattress company says it's the best, which is useless, because "best" isn't something a mattress can be. Best for side sleepers, best for a hot sleeper and best for someone sharing a bed with a 5 a.m. riser are three different mattresses, and that's why most people buy the wrong one and live with it for a decade.
Winning a category is easy: a mattress designed around one problem usually gives up something else. A great cooling bed often has less foam on top, so less pressure relief; a bed that isolates motion perfectly is usually all foam, so it's harder to move on. So for us, best overall is the one that's good at everything at once and doesn't fall apart in any single area. Number one does the most things well; everything below beats it at one thing and loses on the rest.
Quick verdict
If you want one answer, get the Helix Midnight Luxe: it has no weak spot. After that, it's a question of what annoys you most. Waking up hot: the Leesa Sapira Chill. A hotel-feel mattress delivered and set up for you: the Saatva Classic. A partner who moves all night, or a tighter budget: the Nectar Premier. Three firmness choices from a company that builds its own: the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe.
Get Helix Get Leesa Get Saatva Get Nectar Get Brooklyn Bedding
1. Helix Midnight Luxe: best overall
A hybrid with foam on top and coils underneath, at about 6 out of 10 on firmness, the medium to medium-firm zone where most people are comfortable. The coils are zoned: firmer under your hips and midsection, softer under your shoulders. We rate it good on pressure relief, support, edge support and temperature, and it suits side, back and combination sleepers. It isn't the best in the world at any one of those; it's just never bad at any of them, and over eight years of sleeping on something, that matters more than a headline feature.
The drawback: Helix sells a whole lineup, and the Midnight is the model tuned for side and combo sleepers. It's the most popular, so everyone buys it by default, but if you're a heavier back or stomach sleeper it's probably not your Helix. Take the quiz or read which model matches you first.
Price: from about $1,900 for a queen before any sale. The optional Ergo Align lumbar layer is about $187 extra, worth it if your lower back is why you're shopping.
2. Leesa Sapira Chill: for hot sleepers who want a soft top
The pick if you sleep hot but won't give up a soft top to fix it. It's a hybrid in three firmness levels (roughly 4, 6 and 8), built around a cooling cover over foam and coils that breathe. It's good at more than cooling: it scored high on pressure relief and has strong edge support, which matters when you share a bed because you get to use the whole surface.
The drawback: motion isolation is its weakest point. It's a responsive hybrid, and a mattress that springs back fast also passes movement along. If your partner gets up at 5 a.m. and you'd rather not know, this probably isn't the one.
Price: from about $1,700 for a queen, toward the top end for a hybrid queen.
3. Saatva Classic: for people who don't want a bed in a box
A proper innerspring with coils on top of coils, offered in plush soft, luxury firm and firm. It feels like a hotel mattress in the good sense. Saatva delivers it, sets it up in your bedroom and takes the old one away, all included. It's for anyone who likes a traditional feel, wants someone else to handle delivery, or has never liked all-foam beds.
The drawbacks: as an innerspring, motion travels through it more than through foam. And some people find it too firm for the first two weeks or so before it settles; if your first thought is "it's a brick", give it a few weeks before deciding.
Price: from about $1,900 for a queen, with delivery and setup into your bedroom included.
4. Nectar Premier: best for motion isolation and budget
Thirteen inches of memory foam, no coils, at about 6 out of 10 on firmness. Memory foam absorbs movement instead of passing it along, so a partner getting in and out of bed through the night won't wake you as much as on a coil mattress. It also has the longest trial on this list (365 nights) plus a forever warranty, and it's usually the cheapest by a lot.
The drawback: memory foam is slow. It takes a moment to spring back when you move, so you get that slight sense of climbing out of a dip each time you roll over. Combination sleepers who change position all night, and stomach sleepers who need to stay on the surface, will likely be happier on something firmer.
Price: from about $1,000 for a queen, though it moves around a lot with promotions.
5. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe: for firmness choice
A hybrid in three firmness levels (4, 6 and 7) built around a cooling system called GlacioTex, with copper and gel worked into the foam. It scored a perfect mark on support in independent testing and is strong on pressure relief for back and side sleepers. We'd recommend it for someone who wants a firmness choice from a brand that manufactures its own mattresses, which is rare in this industry.
The drawback: it's sold as a cooling mattress, but independent testing put its actual cooling at about average. The cooling is mostly in the cover and foam infusions, which helps at the surface but doesn't move heat the way real airflow does. If you sleep hot, the Leesa may be the better answer. There's also some new-mattress smell for the first few days, which then goes away.
Price: from about $1,700 for a queen.
The five side by side
| Mattress | Type | Queen from | Best for | Drawback |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Helix Midnight Luxe | Zoned hybrid, ~6/10 | ~$1,900 | Most people; side and combo | Wrong Helix for heavier back/stomach sleepers |
| Leesa Sapira Chill | Hybrid, 3 firmnesses | ~$1,700 | Hot sleepers wanting a soft top | Weak motion isolation |
| Saatva Classic | Coil-on-coil innerspring | ~$1,900 | Traditional feel, setup included | Motion transfer; firm at first |
| Nectar Premier | All memory foam, ~6/10 | ~$1,000 | Restless partners, budget | Slow to respond when you move |
| Brooklyn Aurora Luxe | Hybrid, 3 firmnesses | ~$1,700 | Firmness choice | Only average cooling |
Whichever you pick, use the trial. Every mattress here gives at least 100 nights and some give a full year, and your body will tell you within about three to four weeks whether you got it right.
Pros and cons
What works
- Each pick has a clear job, so it's easy to cross the others off.
- Every mattress comes with at least a 100-night trial.
- Prices run from about $1,000 to $1,900 for a queen.
What doesn't
- No single mattress wins every category.
- Coil and responsive hybrids pass along more motion.
- Memory foam can feel slow for combination and stomach sleepers.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best mattress overall?
The Helix Midnight Luxe, because it has no weak spot across pressure relief, support, edges and temperature, and suits side, back and combination sleepers.
What's the best mattress for a hot sleeper?
From this list, the Leesa Sapira Chill, built around a cooling cover over breathable foam and coils.
What's the best cheap mattress here?
The Nectar Premier, from about $1,000 for a queen, with a 365-night trial.
How long should I try a new mattress?
About three to four weeks; your body needs that long to tell you whether it's right. Every mattress here allows at least 100 nights.
Filed under
More in Best Mattresses
Best ofBest Mattress for Hip Pain: 5 Picks That Support Without Digging InFive mattresses compared for hip pressure: Titan Plus Luxe, Birch Natural, Nectar Classic, Saatva RX and Helix Midnight Luxe, with king prices and who each suits.
Best ofBest Mattress for Couples With Different Weights: Build a Split KingWhen two people weigh very differently, one mattress feels firm to one and soft to the other. Here's how to build a split king from two Helix twin XLs, side by side.
Best ofBest Mattress for Hot Sleepers: Five Picks That Hold Less HeatNo mattress cools you down; the right one just holds less of your heat. Five picks with what's inside, what the labs measured, the one catch on each, and the terms.
Best ofBest Mattress for Seniors: Easy In, Easy OutWe tested three mattresses for senior mobility: edge support, how easily you roll over, joint relief and sitting height. Helix Midnight Luxe and Bear Elite Hybrid came out on top.