For most households Good Chop is the better pick: cheaper per pound, a slightly higher Trustpilot rating and no active lawsuit over billing. ButcherBox is for buyers who want certified grass-fed beef and organic chicken by default.
- Medium boxes: Good Chop $149 plus about $10 shipping; ButcherBox $179 with free shipping (at the time of review).
- One independent comparison put Good Chop at about $10 per pound and ButcherBox at roughly $13.50–$16.50 for its smallest box.
- Trustpilot: ButcherBox 4.2 across nearly 4,000 reviews; Good Chop 4.4 across almost 6,000.
- ButcherBox faces an active 2026 class action alleging an unclear cancellation flow; we found no lawsuits against Good Chop.
Some of these are partner links; they cost you nothing extra. How we earn
On this page9 sections
A medium Good Chop box costs $149 and a ButcherBox costs $179, but with these two services the meat is the easy part. What you're really signing up for is a standing arrangement where a company charges your card on its own schedule, and you find out later how easy it is to stop.
We went through the pricing, the sourcing claims, independent comparisons and a few thousand buyer reviews on both, including a billing pattern in both companies' cancellation complaints that you should know about before either one gets your card number.
Quick verdict
Good Chop is the better choice for most households: it costs meaningfully less per pound, its Trustpilot average is slightly higher across a bigger review base, and while its delivery record has real blemishes, it's the only one of the two without active litigation over how it bills and cancels. ButcherBox is the right call for one buyer: the person who left the grocery store for the certifications and will happily pay a per-pound premium to have them chosen by default.
What they have in common
The overlap is bigger than either brand admits: frozen, vacuum-sealed meat delivered to your door, cuts you pick yourself, no antibiotics or added hormones, and a guarantee on the first box. Neither will beat the grocery store on conventional meat prices, so if cheapest per pound is your only criterion, keep buying locally. People sign up for meat the grocery store can't reliably give them, and on that job both deliver.
Sourcing: certificates vs choice
ButcherBox sells the paperwork. Every cut of its beef is 100% grass-fed and grass-finished, and every chicken is certified organic, claims that independent comparison reviews have confirmed. Its beef, pork and bison carry Certified Humane or GAP welfare certification, and the company is a certified B Corporation. If sourcing standards are why you're leaving the grocery store, ButcherBox wins clearly.
Good Chop sells a menu. Grass-fed, USDA Prime and Wagyu are all available, but you have to choose them: an independent review noted that most cuts in a standard box are conventional beef unless you deliberately select otherwise. Where Good Chop wins is geography. Everything comes from US farms and fisheries, which has been independently confirmed, while ButcherBox sources from the US and also Australia, Canada and Norway.
Quality and reviews
ButcherBox sits at 4.2 on Trustpilot across nearly 4,000 reviews, with quality praise the loudest theme and plenty of subscribers five or even eight years in. Good Chop edges it at 4.4 across almost 6,000 reviews, and Serious Eats called it their favorite meat delivery box. One caveat on Good Chop: some Reddit buyers report thin, chewy steaks, while others in the same threads say the basics like ground beef and chicken are solid. Call quality a tie on satisfaction, with ButcherBox holding the premium end and Good Chop the everyday end.
Billing, delivery and cancellation
Hardly anyone on either review page complains about the food. The complaints are about the account.
Good Chop reviews carry a familiar set of complaints: rebilling after cancellation, support that wears people down, and delivery failures. One review reported the company acknowledging that 5,000 boxes were shipped to the wrong addresses, and several subscribers described switching to ButcherBox over logistics and billing. Good Chop replies to 99% of negative reviews, usually within a day, though the replies often read as generic rather than resolving the issue. We found no lawsuits against it.
ButcherBox has faced class actions over cancellation and auto-renewal twice: one filed in 2019 and settled, and a new one filed in 2026 that is still active, alleging the cancellation flow is designed to be unclear. Those are allegations, not findings, but they sit uncomfortably next to a "cancel anytime" pitch. Its refund policy is discretionary: you have 7 days to report a problem, and the terms say filing a claim doesn't guarantee a refund. Recent reviewers describe long hold times while perishable boxes were in transit.
Whichever you choose: cancel through the site well before your billing date, screenshot the confirmation, and check it stuck.
Price and shipping
| Good Chop | ButcherBox | |
|---|---|---|
| Medium box | $149, about 14 lb | $179 (Signature) |
| Shipping | About $10 per box | Free |
| Price per pound (one independent comparison) | About $10 | About $13.50–$16.50 (smallest box) |
| Cheaper plan | — | Essentials, smaller selection |
| Larger boxes | Yes | Yes |
Once shipping is folded in, the box-price gap shrinks to about $20, but per pound is the number that decides dinner, and ButcherBox's certifications cost a few extra dollars on every pound. Promotions change constantly on both, so check live prices. Boxes run from 14 to over 40 lb, so measure your freezer before ordering, and report any box that arrives thawed the same day rather than refreezing it.
Which to pick
- Better value per pound, full customization, US-only sourcing: Good Chop.
- Certified grass-fed beef and organic chicken as the default: ButcherBox.
- Only after the cheapest meat: skip both and shop at the grocery store.
Either way, set a reminder for your billing date before the first box ships, and treat the first-box guarantee as your real trial.
Pros and cons
What works
- Good Chop: about $10 per pound, US-only sourcing, slightly higher Trustpilot rating, no lawsuits found.
- ButcherBox: grass-fed, grass-finished beef and organic chicken by default, welfare certifications, free shipping.
- Both: no antibiotics or added hormones, pick-your-own cuts, a first-box guarantee.
What doesn't
- Good Chop: premium cuts must be chosen; delivery and rebilling complaints; some thin steaks reported.
- ButcherBox: higher per-pound cost, imported sourcing, discretionary refunds, an active cancellation class action.
- Both: subscription billing that needs watching; boxes need serious freezer space.
Frequently asked questions
Is Good Chop cheaper than ButcherBox?
Yes. At the time of review a medium box was $149 vs $179, and one independent comparison put Good Chop at about $10 per pound vs roughly $13.50–$16.50 for ButcherBox's smallest box. Good Chop charges about $10 shipping; ButcherBox ships free.
Which has better-sourced meat?
ButcherBox, by default: 100% grass-fed, grass-finished beef, certified organic chicken and welfare certifications. Good Chop offers grass-fed and premium cuts but you have to select them; its advantage is US-only sourcing.
Is it hard to cancel?
Both have cancellation and rebilling complaints, and ButcherBox faces an active 2026 class action alleging an unclear cancellation flow. Cancel well before your billing date and keep a screenshot of the confirmation.
Filed under
